WHAT YOU SAID

• I have listened to 200 episodes of two men being wrong about music and I have never once been tempted to stop.

  bleakhouse_dadApple Podcasts · Aug 2026★★★★★

  Framed this one. — G

• Started listening to make fun of albums I hate. Now I own four of them on vinyl. This podcast is a financial hazard.

  Renata M.Apple Podcasts · Jul 2026★★★★★

• Two stars. They were mean about Creed and Creed is good actually.

  AnonymousApple Podcasts · Jun 2026★★

  We're keeping this one up forever. — T

• The Space Jam episode made me laugh so hard on a plane that a man asked what I was listening to and I lied to him.

  @hollowpointTwitter · May 2026

• My dad and I don't agree on anything anymore except that Tim is wrong about Jimmy Buffett. It's the only thing we text about.

  MarcusEmail · Sep 2026

  Genuinely the nicest email we've ever got. — G

• You spent eleven minutes on the drum sound and never once said whether you liked the record. I have never felt more seen or more annoyed.

  Dana, PortlandEmail · Aug 2026

• This is the only podcast where I've learned actual music history by accident while two guys argue about whether a man can legally call himself a lawyer.

  u/quietstorm_77Reddit · Apr 2026

• listened to the whole GG Allin two-parter in one sitting and now I need to be alone for a while

  @mothgirl.wavInstagram · Mar 2026

• The prepisodes are the best part and I will die on this hill. Thirty minutes on one bad song is the correct amount of time.

  sludgepopSpotify · Jul 2026★★★★★

• I don't even like music criticism. I like these two specific idiots.

  H. OkonkwoSpotify · Feb 2026★★★★★

  Correct. — T

• Please stop doing the voice. I'm begging. My wife has started doing the voice.

  @dad_of_three_regretsTwitter · Jun 2026

• Three hundred episodes in and the bit where they pretend to know what a compressor does has not gotten old.

  KevYouTube · May 2026

NOTHING FROM THERE YET